Rarest commendations

Ranked by the share of pirates on the Progress Tracker who have completed each, rarest first.

Counted from imports on Nov 21, 2026. Pirates who track their progress tend to be completionists, so these shares run higher than they would across every player. The rarest cosmetics are ranked the same way.

Completed by under 10% of pirates

27 commendations
4%Guardians of FortuneFavoured SailorAfter receiving your Blessing, sail miles while representing the Guardians of Fortune.4%Guardians of FortuneThese Waters are DefendedSail miles while representing the Guardians of Fortune.4%Servants of the FlameTravelled ServantAfter the Ritual of the Flame, sail miles while representing the Servants of the Flame.5%Servants of the FlameEmpire of FlameSail miles while representing the Servants of the Flame.6%Adventures At Sea · Shrouded Spoils"Hunter of The Shrouded Ghost" TitleUnlock 'Hunter of The Shrouded Ghost' commendation.6%Adventures At Sea · Last Ship StandingConqueror of the DamnedWin battles in Last Ship Standing.6%Adventures At Sea · Shrouded SpoilsHunter of the Shrouded GhostDefeat the Shrouded Ghost in a chance encounter.6%Reaper’s BonesSailor of Scorching SeasSail 1000 nautical miles on Reaper's Bones Voyages, or with their Emissary Flag raised.7%Hunter’s Call · Call of the HunterCall of the HunterComplete 250 Hunter's Call Voyages.7%Hunter’s Call · Call of the HunterHunter of the Grisly MawSell 50 Grisly Megalodon Teeth to The Hunter's Call.7%Hunter’s Call · Call of the HunterHunter of the Wide SeaSail 1000 nautical miles on Hunter's Call Voyages, or with their Emissary Flag raised.7%Reaper’s BonesHunter's Call HeistedSell 480 Hunter's Call treasures to The Reaper's Bones.7%Guardians of FortuneToo Many to CountAfter receiving your Blessing, sink ships while representing the Guardians of Fortune in Faction Battles.7%Hunter’s Call · Call of the Hunter‘Call of the Hunter’ TitleComplete the 'Call of the Hunter' Commendation.7%Hunter’s Call · Call of the Hunter‘Hunter of the Grisly Maw’ TitleComplete the 'Hunter of the Grisly Maw' Commendation.7%Hunter’s Call · Call of the Hunter‘Hunter of the Wide Sea’ TitleComplete the 'Hunter of the Wide Sea' Commendation.8%Servants of the FlameIn His NameReach the Allegiance Streak to become a Champion or win battles as a Champion after the Ritual of the Flame.8%Guardians of FortunePretty Good at ThisReach the Allegiance Streak to become a Champion or win battles as a Champion after the Blessing of Athena's Fortune.8%Servants of the FlameRack Them UpAfter the Ritual of the Flame, sink ships while representing the Servants of the Flame in Faction Battles.8%Reaper’s BonesReaper of Master's OfferingsSell Caskets of Gilded Bones, Caskets of Battle Bones, Reaper Master's Urns or Reaper Warrior's Urns.9%Guardians of FortuneBest of the BestReach the Allegiance Streak to become a Champion or win battles as a Champion.9%Servants of the FlameBone VoyageComplete a Ghost Ship battle while wearing the Skeleton Curse.9%Servants of the FlameFerocious WarriorReach the Allegiance Streak to become a Champion or win battles as a Champion.9%Reaper’s BonesHunter's Call HuntedAs an Emissary, sell 25 stolen Hunter's Call Emissary Flags to The Reaper's Bones.9%Creator CrewPirate StorytellerHave 20 concurrent viewers.9%Guardians of FortuneRunning the RiskAfter receiving your Blessing, sink ships as a Grade 5 Athena's Fortune Emissary representing the Guardians of Fortune in Faction Battles.9%Athena’s FortuneVeil SeekerComplete 100 Legend of the Veil Voyages.

Completed by 10% to 24% of pirates

254 commendations

Completed by 25% to 49% of pirates

598 commendations

Completed by 50% to 74% of pirates

414 commendations

Completed by 75% to 89% of pirates

116 commendations

Completed by 90% of pirates or more

31 commendations